Using "Time-Out" in Disciplining Young Children

During the 1950s and '60s behavioral approachesmeasurement techniques.
in psychotherapy, counseling, education, and"Time out was the term for extinction used in
parent training became widely used. "Time out"teaching and training children. It refers to time out
derives from the operant conditioning literaturefrom positive reinforcement. It was believed that
expanded and popularized to a large degree bymany inappropriate behaviors of children are
Harvard psychologist B. F. Skinner. Experimenrtslearned as attention-getting strategies. Tangible
with animals revealed two major types ofrewards often were replaced by praise and
learning. Classical conditioning originated from therecognition. Social reinforcement can be as
work of Russian physiologist, Ivan Pavlov, at thepowerful or even more powerful that tangible
turn of the century, and involves the pairing ofrewards. The use of the procedure was never
two stimuli. An unconditioned stimulus is one thatmeant to be a punishment. It is applied
elicits some behavioral response, much like aconsistently by removing the child from whatever
reflex.conditions are rewarding the behavior for a short
A conditioned stimulus, originally having no powerperiod of time. Ideally, the "time out room" is
to elicit that response, paired predictably with thedevoid of positively stimulating objects. In certain
unconditioned stimulus acquires the power to elicithospitals and institutions for the mentally
that same response. Psychologists believed forchallenged this was inappropriately applied to
many years that this was the basis for emotionalpadded cells used for long periods of time for
learning but not the learning of most behavioraldangerous behaviors.
habits. Skinner established many of theParents using time out should be aware of the
parameters of learning that occurs on the basispsychological basis for the procedure. A child
of the consequences of that behavior. A ratshould not be placed in a room with access to
learns to press a bar when the bar press leads toTV, videogames, ipods and the like. The reason
reward with a pellet of food. Any outcome thatfor the time out should be explained clearly but
increases the likelihood of a response is termed abriefly. There whould be no discussion. A one-time
"reinforcement" A learned response will bewarning should be given before time out is
"extinguished"over time when it no longer leads toinstiituted. After a brief time out interval-perhaps
the reinforcement.five minutes, the child should be returned to what
Students of Skinner and other psychologistshe was doing. Suggestions for more appropriate
began to apply operant conditioning procedures toways he could have handled his frustration may
human learning. Teachers and parents had a longbe given,. Should the negative behavior continue
history of awarding stars and stickers to childrenthe time out can be re-instituted.
for good performance. Now there was a solidIt is sometimes necessary to physically place the
empirical basis for such procedures which werechild in time out. The procedure, therefore, is not
seen as having potential for changing behaviors inappropriate for older children and adolescents.
schools, psychiatric hospitals treatment centers,Older children and adolescents may be sent to
even prisons. Educators began using operanttheir rooms but this is not time out and usually
conditioning in classrooms. Therapists used it fornot as effective. The best approach is to teach a
toilet training, and for teaching language, dressingmore socially positive behavior incompatible with
skills, and a wide variety of social skills. Psychiatricthe negative behavior she was using. Operant
settings were often structured as with "tokenconditioning procedures for changing human
reward" systems for training pro-social behaviors.behavior today are combined with cognitive
The difference from earlier approaches was thatapproaches designed to restructure irrational and
the reinforcement procedures were now beingself-defeating ideas that lead to the undesirable
applied systematically and often with precisebehavior.